I get it. Many of us are terrified that we’re witnessing the final days of the American experiment. We fear another four years of Donald Trump will result in the end of the Republic and the slide into autocracy… or worse. So those of us who frequent the inter-webs, and play around with social media have set aside the cute cat videos, and kids doing adorable things, and are talking politics.
A lot.
But we’re not doing it very well. Or at least a subset of us aren’t. Because this feels like the most important election of our lives (News Flash — it is) we’re all pretty passionate about our preferred candidate running for the democratic nomination. And that’s good. An engaged citizenry can be a bulwark against tyranny.
While I have a preferred candidate I tend to keep my Tweets focused on more general issues — corruption of the DOJ, Republican cowardice, the rightwing assault on voting rights, etc. But I do dip into various candidates Twitter feeds to get a sense of their positions on various issues. And what I have seen there is ugly.
Often silly or baseless memes or emojis or gifs that offer nothing beyond an insult. And yes, the candidates are big boys and girls. They put themselves in the public arena so they can endure the slings and arrows though to be sure it does not reflect well on the intellect of that particular person who left the post. Aren’t we supposed to be the pro-science, pro-reading, pro-maps, pro-math party. We’re not able to marshal a cogent debate regarding policies, and are reduced to pictures?
But oft times these attacks are personal, vicious, and threatening and when they are directed at that particular candidate’s supporters, that’s when it’s no longer okay, and it is making me despair for our civilization.
You don’t like candidate A or C or Z? Great, don’t vote for them in your state’s primary, but to simply fling feces at other people is not going to help your candidate nor will you come off well in the marketplace of ideas.
So here’s a suggestion. On our own Twitter feeds or Facebook pages by all means advocate for the candidate of our choice. Tell me in clear, unequivocal language their positions on the issues. Why you approve of these stances. You can compare and contrast with other candidate’s position if it’s done with honesty and integrity.
What none of us should do is go onto another person’s personal wall or feed and verbally assault them for their choice. I welcome honest debate and discussion where you can say, “I understand you like F’s position on money in politics, but have you considered this other alternative that my candidate, Y, is offering?” It’s also damn rude to go onto a candidate’s feed and behalf like ill-bred monsters. Trust me it’s not going to incline the people hanging out there to suddenly switch to your candidate, and it also forces people to retreat into silence.
And right now we don’t need more silence. We need to be calling out the corruption, illegal actions, authoritarian actions of the Trump administration, giving each other strength and encouragement for the fight. Because the fight cannot be, must not be between ourselves.
We know the threat. It’s Donald Trump and his Republican enablers. Taking liberties with Caesar Rodney’s speech from the play 1776 after a brawl has broken out in the Continental Congress —
Caesar Rodney: Stop it! Stop it! This is America! Stop it! The enemy is out there.
John Dickinson: No, Mr. Rodney, the enemy is here!
Caesar Rodney: No, I say he’s out there! Trump! Trump closing in! Cutting off our air! There’s no time!
And there is no time. Remember that other people working to defeat Trump are not your enemies even if they don’t support your candidate. Advocate for your choice. Canvass and donate. Vote on primary day. But then by god, let us come together. For if we don’t “[ ]most assuredly, we shall all hang separately.” Benjamin Franklin.
I loved the title of this article and I hoped it was a well-reasoned call for civility for ALL sides. Nope. It’s just a call for the Left to be civil to each other in their attempt to topple Trump. Apparently, civility is not permitted for rubes who are ignorant enough to follow Trump. A very disappointing read.
Your comment rather indicated why I didn’t discuss the MAGA crowd. Honestly, I feel they are beyond reach. Perhaps someday some of them will awaken, the fever will break and they will feel shame, but for now they are lost. And they also come onto the feeds of other people and fling insults so perhaps a few of them might take it to heart, though I doubt it. Within the Trump cult the cruelty is the point. My major concern is that those of us who oppose this administration don’t leave our eventual nominee — whomever it might be — so wounded that we are unable to defeat Trump and his enablers who are actively destroying the rule of the law and our democratic norms. But thank you for commenting. I should perhaps have been more clear.
Wouldn’t that be nice? However, I have yet to encounter a hardcore Trump supporter engage in anything resembling civility. It always devolves into logical fallacies, with ad hominem attacks being their favorite. This is in sharp contrast to actual conservatives, who it’s pretty easy to have a rational conversation with.
For the MAGAs it has stopped being politics and has become something more akin to religion. It truly is a cult, and at it’s most extreme you get those poor fools who have been sucked into the Q vortex. They really are beyond help. Perhaps someday the fever will break. Right now all we can try to do is vote in overwhelming numbers and treat moderate Republicans who have been sickened by Trump with respect and welcome them to our side. It’s going to take all of us to pull the country back from the abyss.